Many comment-to-DM setups send the link straight away: someone comments, the link arrives. It seems efficient, but it usually leaves results on the table. A short opening message with a button first, then the link, tends to work better.
This guide explains the rule behind it, why it lifts results, how to write the opening message and the button, and when you can skip it.
The rule behind it
Instagram allows one private reply to a comment. That reply is your only message until the person answers (see the rules). If it contains the link, that's it: no follow-up, no email question, no reminder.
A button changes that. When the person taps it, Instagram treats the tap as their answer. Now the 24-hour messaging window is open, and you can send the link and anything else that helps.
Think of it as a door. The opening message knocks. The tap opens the door. Everything else happens inside.
Link first vs button first
| Link in the first message | Opening DM with button | |
|---|---|---|
| Messages possible | One | Several, within 24 hours |
| Reminder for non-clickers | Not possible | Possible |
| Ask for email or follow | Not possible | Possible |
| Link arrives when | Immediately, maybe unseen | Right after a tap, while they're looking |
| Click tracking per person | Limited | Clear, step by step |
Why it lifts results
- The DM gets opened. A short, personal message stands out in the message requests. People tap because they asked for something.
- The link arrives when they're ready. They tapped "Send me the link", so they're looking at the chat when it arrives.
- You can do more. Ask for an email, check if they follow you, or send one reminder later.
- It feels like a conversation, not a broadcast.
- You learn more. You see who tapped and who clicked, so you know where people drop off.
Message requests: why the first message must be short
If someone doesn't follow you, your message often lands in their message requests, not the main inbox. They see a preview: your name and the first line. A long first message gets cut off. A short, friendly one ("Here's what you asked for!") gets tapped.
How to write the opening DM
Keep it short: two sentences, one of them telling people to tap.
Hey, glad you're here! Tap below and I'll send you the plan right away.
What makes it work:
- A warm greeting. Short and friendly, the way you'd start a chat yourself.
- A reference to what they asked for. "the plan", "the prices", "the code".
- A clear next step. "Tap below".
More examples:
Hi! Thanks for asking. Tap the button and I'll send you our price list.
Hey! Love that you want the recipe. One tap and it's yours.
Here's the code you asked for. Tap below to get it.
How to write the button
The button text is what the person "says" when they tap. Write it in their words, about what they'll get. Instagram limits button text to 20 characters, so keep it tight.
Twenty button texts that work:
- Send me the plan
- Send me the link
- Get my code
- Show me the prices
- Get the recipe
- Send the guide
- Yes, send it
- Get the checklist
- I want the list
- Get the template
- Show me the map
- Get the size guide
- Save my seat
- Send the replay
- Book my call
- Get early access
- Show me the menu
- Get the preset
- Send the notes
- Get the workout
Avoid "Click here", "OK" or "Yes" alone. They don't say what happens.
Make it personal without a name
A first name makes a message feel personal, but Instagram doesn't reliably share it with tools. A half-filled "Hey {name}" looks worse than no name at all, so Pidgo sends your text exactly as written. Make the opening personal through what you say instead: mention the post they commented on and what they asked for.
Write variations
If a post gets hundreds of comments, every person gets the same opening message. That's fine, but a few variations make it feel less like a broadcast and keep public perception natural. Pidgo can pick randomly from several versions of the opening message. Keep the meaning identical and only vary the wording.
When to skip the button
If all you send is a link and you don't want follow-ups, a single message with the link is fine. It's simpler for people who comment and run. Examples:
- A quick product link on a post where people buy right away.
- An event link for something happening in the next hour.
For most lead-generation setups, the button is worth it.
You also skip it whenever the person wrote to you first. A story reply, a story mention or a DM with your word already opened the conversation, so Pidgo Stories, Pidgo Mentions and Pidgo DMs send the link or the thank-you straight away, and follow first, email and reminders still work. Comments during a Live are like post comments: Pidgo Live starts with the opening DM and a button.
What happens after the tap
The tap opens the conversation. From there, Pidgo can:
- Ask people to follow you before the link (optional).
- Ask for their email (optional).
- Send the link, tracked so you see clicks.
- Send one reminder if they didn't click.
Common mistakes
- A long opening message. It gets cut off in the preview. Two sentences.
- The link in the opening message anyway. Then the button has no purpose.
- A vague button. "Continue" doesn't say what happens.
- A stiff greeting. "Dear user," feels like a form letter.
- Promising something else in the DM than in the reel. People notice.
Questions people ask
Do fewer people get the link because of the extra tap?
Some people won't tap. In return, those who do are more likely to open the link, and you can send a reminder. Measure it for your own audience: Pidgo shows how many got a DM, tapped, got the link and clicked.
Can I send a link in the opening DM and still use a button?
You can, but it defeats the purpose. Keep the opening DM short and save the link for after the tap.
What does the button look like for the follower?
It appears as a tappable reply option under your message in the Instagram chat. Tapping it sends the button text as their reply.
What if someone types a reply instead of tapping?
Their message lands in your normal Instagram inbox, and you can answer by hand. Pidgo continues the automated flow when the button is tapped, so make the button text clear enough that tapping is the obvious next step.
How long is the button valid?
The person can tap it as long as the conversation exists, but follow-up messages only work within 24 hours of their last message.